By: Mordechai Avigdor, Esq.
For me, it always seems to happen not just on Erev Shabbos, but on an Erev Shabbos when I need
to get from Brooklyn to Lakewood for a family Shabbos sheva brachos.
The call came in to the Chayim Aruchim hotline from Kalman* who desperately needed help. His
mother, Sara, was in the intensive care unit of a Queens hospital and had been intubated, breathing
only with the help of a tube inserted into her trachea. Kalman and his siblings were at an impasse,
with Kalman the sole voice insisting that the hospital should be instructed to take all lifesaving
measures needed if a medical emergency arose. Kalmanâ€™s siblings felt that Sara should not be
subjected to superseding intervening medical procedures and that since there appeared to be no
hope for recovery, there was no point in prolonging Saraâ€™s death. Kalman disagreed, feeling strongly
that he was prolonging his motherâ€™s life, not her death.
Not having executed a health care proxy or any other instructions regarding her medical care, there
was no proof of Saraâ€™s wishes in this kind of scenario. Kalmanâ€™s four siblings insisted that their
mother had appointed them her health care proxy and expressed her preference not to have her life
prolonged, but Kalman doubted those claims and contacted Chayim Aruchim. The Chayim Aruchim
team tried their best to settle things between the siblings but it became clear very quickly that there
was no choice but to pursue the legal route, going so far as to have Chayim Aruchim cover some of
the associated expenses.
The call came to me on my way home from Thursday night sheva brachos in Lakewood. Having
married off a child that week, I was exhausted from the many trips back and forth but I read the
papers carefully when I received them at 11 PM. This was not a question of life or death; it was a
certain death. Without action, the IV which provided nutrition and hydration would be removed and
Sara would die of starvation or dehydration as per the instructions given by Kalmanâ€™s siblings to the
A hearing was scheduled for a restraining order the next morning in Queens Supreme Court.
Everyone wanted to proceed with the case quickly and jurisdictional objections and acknowledgment
of receipt of legal papers were waived by the parties, with the judgeâ€™s approval. The case was
clear: the petitioners and respondents had conflicting opinions with respect to their motherâ€™s wishes
for her end of life medical care. The siblings asserted that Sara did not want to live with a respirator
and feeding tube, while Kalman denied that claim. The judge was informed that Sara was at times
lucid, and during those periods had purportedly expressed her desires to her family. The siblings
represented to the court that the hospital planned to extubate Sarah in the very near future, which
meant certain death without Kalmanâ€™s intervention.
The hearing dragged on and on, with a change in venue to a different courthouse. By 3 oâ€™clock I
called my wife and told her that if I wasnâ€™t home by 4 PM she should go to Shabbos sheva brachos
in Lakewood without me. Ironically, we had put the same plan into play two years earlier for the
Shabbos sheva brachos of my older son and while I felt bad at the prospect of missing a family
simcha, I had no choice. I needed to stay in Queens and try to save Sarahâ€™s life and if that meant to
miss my sonâ€™s sheva brachos, I would do that. It was an easy call to make it, albeit one with tough
I made a motion to the judge to adjourn for Shabbos, while keeping the injunction in place, but he
denied the motion, telling me that Shabbos didnâ€™t start until 7:15 PM. Needing further evidence, the
judge rushed over to the hospital himself with the court officer and stenographer and concluded that
Sara was unable to give medical directives for herself. In light of the lack of a health care proxy, his
restraining order would remain in effect and Sara would live to see another day.
My wife had decided to stick it out with me and with the judgeâ€™s permission to leave, I left and drove
back to Brooklyn. While I never intentionally leave to Lakewood without a three hour window, in this
case I was too emotionally exhausted and physically drained to notice the time. My wife drove to
Lakewood, rather quickly, while I fell asleep in the car. We arrived 35 minutes before Shabbos,
unpacked quickly and joined the simcha.
Three weeks after the court hearing, I spoke to Kalman. Sara was released from the hospital and
was recuperating in a nursing home facility in Queens. She was no longer intubated and was once
again talking to her family and friends.
All I could think was, â€œBaruch Hashem. She is alive.â€ Thank you Hashem that we have here such a
wonderful organization Like Chayim Aruchim that enabled me to take part in saving that life.
No one knows the day of their own petira, but everyone must respect the kedushas hachaim we all
possess, even chayei shaa. As for the â€œlifeâ€ we do have, letâ€™s make the best of it.
I believe that is Chayim Aruchimâ€™s mission.
P.S. The Shabbos sheva brachos were especially beautiful and I promised my wife not to leave so
late anymoreâ€¦ But she knows better.
*Names have been changed in the interests of privacy.